1.
Randomized trial of weight loss in primary breast cancer: Impact on body composition, circulating biomarkers and tumor characteristics.
Demark-Wahnefried, W, Rogers, LQ, Gibson, JT, Harada, S, Frugé, AD, Oster, RA, Grizzle, WE, Norian, LA, Yang, ES, Della Manna, D, et al
International journal of cancer. 2020;146(10):2784-2796
-
-
-
Free full text
-
Plain language summary
Obesity directly impacts survival in individuals with breast cancer. Previous studies in animals and at the cellular level have shown that calorie restriction and increased physical activity to achieve a negative energy balance may inhibit cancer progression, however effects in patients are unknown. This randomised control trial aimed to determine the impact of a pre surgery weight loss programme in 32 women with breast cancer on tumour biology and other markers of disease. The results were mixed and showed that proteins which bind to hormones involved in breast cancer were increased, which could decrease severity of disease. However, tumour biology was negatively affected; specific genes involved in breast cancer progression were increased and those involved in tumour suppression were decreased. Although this did result in no net effect on the rate at which new tumours were formed. It was concluded that although the study showed mixed results, ultimately the rate at which new tumours were formed remained unaffected. This trial could be used by healthcare professionals to understand that the role of negative energy intake in breast cancer development is complicated and warrants further research.
Abstract
Obesity adversely impacts overall and cancer-specific survival among breast cancer patients. Preclinical studies demonstrate negative energy balance inhibits cancer progression; however, feasibility and effects in patients are unknown. A two-arm, single-blinded, randomized controlled weight-loss trial was undertaken presurgery among 32 overweight/obese, Stage 0-II breast cancer patients. The attention control arm (AC) received basic nutritional counseling and upper-body progressive resistance training whereas the weight loss intervention (WLI) arm received identical guidance, plus counseling on caloric restriction and aerobic exercise to promote 0.68-0.92 kg/week weight loss. Anthropometrics, body composition, blood and survey data were collected at baseline and presurgery ∼30 days later. Tumor markers (e.g., Ki67) and gene expression were assessed on biopsy and surgical specimens; sera were analyzed for cytokines, growth and metabolic factors. Significant WLI vs. AC differences were seen in baseline-to-follow-up changes in weight (-3.62 vs. -0.52 kg), %body fat (-1.3 vs. 0%), moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (+224 vs. +115 min/week), caloric density (-0.3 vs. 0 kcal/g), serum leptin (-12.3 vs. -4.0 ng/dl) and upregulation of tumor PI3Kinase signaling and cell cycle-apoptosis related genes (CC-ARG; all p-values <0.05). Cytolytic CD56dim NK cell expression was positively associated with weight loss; CC-ARG increased with physical activity. Increased tumor (nuclear) TNFα and IL-1β, CX3CL1 and CXCL1 gene expression was observed in the WLI. Tumor Ki67 did not differ between arms. Feasibility benchmarks included 80% accrual, 100% retention, no adverse effects and excellent adherence. Short-term weight loss interventions are feasible; however, mixed effects on tumor biology suggest unclear benefit to presurgical caloric restriction, but possible benefits of physical activity.
2.
Metabolic Slowing and Reduced Oxidative Damage with Sustained Caloric Restriction Support the Rate of Living and Oxidative Damage Theories of Aging.
Redman, LM, Smith, SR, Burton, JH, Martin, CK, Il'yasova, D, Ravussin, E
Cell metabolism. 2018;27(4):805-815.e4
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
Following a calorie-restricted diet while maintaining adequate nutrition is known to have a beneficial effect on increasing longevity and promoting healthy ageing. Oxidative stress resulting from reactive oxygen species formation in mitochondria plays a role in accelerating ageing by damaging DNA, proteins and lipids. A calorie-restriction diet can reduce oxidative stress and cause metabolic adaptations. In this ancillary study, non-obese participants were randomly assigned to either a calorie restriction group which followed 25% calorie restriction while getting adequate nutritional support through supplementation or to a control group which included ad libitum calorie intake. After 2 years of intervention, participants in the calorie restriction group achieved 15% calorie restriction, 8.7kg weight loss and a reduction in 24-hour energy expenditure and sleep energy expenditure beyond weight loss because of metabolic adaptation. Oxidative stress and thyroid axis activity were also reduced in the calorie restriction group. Further robust studies are required to evaluate the effectiveness of calorie restriction in metabolic adaptation and oxidative stress and its effects on ageing. The results of this study can be used by healthcare professionals to understand the benefits of a nutritionally adequate calorie restriction diet on adjusting metabolic processes.
Abstract
Calorie restriction (CR) is a dietary intervention with potential benefits for healthspan improvement and lifespan extension. In 53 (34 CR and 19 control) non-obese adults, we tested the hypothesis that energy expenditure (EE) and its endocrine mediators are reduced with a CR diet over 2 years. Approximately 15% CR was achieved over 2 years, resulting in an average 8.7 kg weight loss, whereas controls gained 1.8 kg. In the CR group, EE measured over 24 hr or during sleep was approximately 80-120 kcal/day lower than expected on the basis of weight loss, indicating sustained metabolic adaptation over 2 years. This metabolic adaptation was accompanied by significantly reduced thyroid axis activity and reactive oxygen species (F2-isoprostane) production. Findings from this 2-year CR trial in healthy, non-obese humans provide new evidence of persistent metabolic slowing accompanied by reduced oxidative stress, which supports the rate of living and oxidative damage theories of mammalian aging.