There is a common belief amongst the general population that a vegan diet leads to lower exercise performance due to the potential lack of dietary protein and nutrients. However, previous research that compared aerobic capacity and muscle strength between different diet groups only showed marginal variance, if any at all. But it is criticized that these studies did not always distinguish between the multiple subtypes of vegetarian or veganism. Hence this study sought to focus specifically on the comparison of strict plant-based eaters with omnivores. The participants involved were 56 active women, around their mid-twenties, with an average Body Mass Index of 22. Assessed were estimated VO2 max (an indicator of aerobic fitness), submaximal endurance performance and upper and lower body muscle strength. The 3-day food diaries of each participant was analysed and showed a similar intake of energy and fats in both groups. Vegans had higher carbohydrate, fibre, vitamin C, iron, and magnesium consumption and lower intake of protein, leucine, alanine, saturated fat, vitamin D, and vitamin B12, when compared to omnivores. Whilst upper body strength appeared to be marginally lower in the vegan group, higher levels of estimated VO2 max and significantly higher submaximal endurance levels were observed. The results contradict the common belief, demonstrating that a vegan diet appears to have no detrimental impact on endurance and muscle strength in healthy, young and lean women. In fact, the findings suggest that a vegan diet can be advantageous on endurance performance compared to omnivores. The authors propose that the higher intake of carbohydrates amongst vegans could be linked to better endurance performance and that such a plant-based diet can have favourable effects on oxidative stress and inflammatory profiles. The outcomes of this study may be of interest to those supporting the sports performance of strict plant-based eaters.