-
1.
The Influence of Nutritional Intervention in the Treatment of Hashimoto's Thyroiditis-A Systematic Review.
Osowiecka, K, Myszkowska-Ryciak, J
Nutrients. 2023;15(4)
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
Hashimoto’s thyroiditis is an autoimmune disorder characterized by the presence of antibodies in the thyroid gland such as thyroid peroxidase (TPO) and thyroglobulin (TG) antibodies. Immune-mediated inflammatory responses eventually lead to the progressive destruction of the gland and impaired thyroid function. The disease has a strong genetic disposition but is also influenced by environmental factors, including diet. Hence diet has been considered a complementary tool to manage thyroid function and disease progression by harnessing the benefits of certain nutrients and anti-inflammatory properties. This systematic review examined the effects of nutrients and dietary interventions on Hashimoto’s disease in current literature. Using antibody levels, thyroid hormone levels and body weight to measure outcomes. The review included 9 studies, all of which compared the intervention group to the control groups. The trials included looked at gluten-free, lactose-free and energy-restricted diets, with or without selected nutrients and foods supplements (ie. Nigella sativa, iodine). The intervention duration ranged from 3 weeks to 12 months. Despite the small number of trials, the data from those studies included in this review showed promising results. Improvements in disease parameters were observed in diets that were energy deficient, eliminated gluten, lactose and goitrogens or added Nigella sativa. Iodine restrictions did not show any improvements. In the discussion section, the authors presented the results in the wider context and the findings from other studies. Ultimately there appears to be a wide variance in outcomes, usually ranging from beneficial to neutral. The authors contributed to such variability due to the complexity of the condition and many influencing factors. Often participants in trials have highly variable thyroid status and function, and differences in regular dietary intakes of nutrients critical to thyroid health can easily distort the results. Hence much more specific research is needed to make firmer conclusions. Whereby no clear conclusions in larger groups could be drawn, potential benefits of dietary interventions in Hashimoto's disease may be much more apparent in clinical settings with personalized approaches that account for such individual variances.
Abstract
Diet can be a complementary treatment for Hashimoto's disease by affecting thyroid function and anti-inflammatory properties. It is still unclear which dietary strategy would be the most beneficial. The aim of this systematic review is to examine all the data currently available in the literature on the effects of nutritional intervention on biochemical parameters (anti-thyroid antibody and thyroid hormones levels) and characteristic symptoms in the course of Hashimoto's thyroiditis. This systematic review was prepared based on PRISMA guidelines. Articles in PubMed and Scopus databases published up to November 2022 were searched. As a result of the selection, out of 1350 publications, 9 were included for further analysis. The nutritional interventions included the following: elimination of gluten (3 articles) or lactose (1 article), energy restriction with or without excluding selected foods (n = 2), consumption of Nigella sativa (n = 2), or dietary iodine restriction (n = 1). The intervention duration ranged from 21 days to 12 months and included individuals with various thyroid function. Of the nine studies, three studies were female only. An improvement was observed during an energy deficit and after the elimination of selected ingredients (e.g., gluten, lactose, or goitrogens), as well as after the intervention of Nigella sativa. These interventions improved antibody levels against peroxidase (anti-TPO), (thyrotropin) TSH, and free thyroxine (fT4). No improvement was seen on the iodine-restricted diet. Varied outcomes of analyzed dietary interventions may be due to the heterogeneous thyroid condition, high variability between patients, and differences in habitual intake of critical nutrients (e.g., iodine, selenium, and iron) in different populations. Therefore, there is a great need for further experimental studies to determine whether any nutritional interventions are beneficial in Hashimoto's disease.
-
2.
The effect of gluten in adolescents and young adults with gastrointestinal symptoms: a blinded randomised cross-over trial.
Crawley, C, Savino, N, Halby, C, Sander, SD, Andersen, AN, Arumugam, M, Murray, J, Christensen, R, Husby, S
Alimentary pharmacology & therapeutics. 2022;55(9):1116-1127
-
-
-
Free full text
-
Plain language summary
The gluten-free diet (GFD) has gained increasing popularity among healthy people without coeliac disease or wheat allergy. The main reasons for following a GFD are weight control, the perception that a GFD is healthier, and the presence of symptoms after gluten ingestion. The aim of this study was to address the hypothesis that adding gluten to the diet results in a self-reported worsening of gastrointestinal symptoms (primary outcome) and mental health (key secondary outcomes) in a well-characterised group of adolescents. This study was arranged in two phases; the first phase began with 2 weeks of a GFD, and if the participants responded to the GFD, they proceeded to phase 2. Phase 2 was a double-blinded randomised trial with cross-over and consisted of three periods, each lasting 7 days: (1) a challenge with gluten/placebo, (2) wash-out phase, and (3) the second challenge with placebo/gluten. Results show that it was not possible to detect a difference in symptoms between gluten and placebo at a group level. Furthermore, on an individual level, there was a comparable number of gluten responders and placebo responders, underscoring the insignificant difference between gluten and placebo. Authors conclude that adding gluten to the diet does not induce gastrointestinal symptoms or worsened mental health in adolescents.
Abstract
BACKGROUND The popularity of the gluten-free diet and sales of gluten-free products have increased immensely. AIMS To investigate whether gluten induces gastrointestinal symptoms, measured by self-reported questionnaires, as well as mental health symptoms in adolescents from a population-based cohort. METHODS The eligible participants (n = 273) were recruited from a population-based cohort of 1266 adolescents and had at least four different gastrointestinal symptoms. Phase one (n = 54) was a run-in phase where the participants lived gluten-free for 2 weeks. If they improved they continued to phase 2 (n = 33), a blinded randomised cross-over trial. Participants were blindly randomised either to start with 7 days of gluten, eating two granola bars containing 10 g of gluten or to 7 days on placebo, eating two granola bars without gluten, followed by the reverse and separated by a 7-day washout period. The effects of the intervention on gastrointestinal symptoms and mental health symptoms were assessed. RESULTS In total, 54/273 participants entered the run-in phase and 35 were eligible for randomization. A total of 33 were randomised and 32 completed the trial. The median age was 20.3 (IQR 19.2-20.9) and 32/33 participants were females. Compared with a placebo, gluten did not induce gastrointestinal symptoms. The difference in the average VAS was -0.01 (95% confidence interval -2.07 to 2.05). Nor did we find a difference in the outcomes measuring mental health. CONCLUSION Compared with placebo, adding gluten to the diet did not induce gastrointestinal symptoms or worsened mental health in adolescents recruited from a population-based cohort. The trial registration number is NCT04639921.
-
3.
The Association between ADHD and Celiac Disease in Children.
Gaur, S
Children (Basel, Switzerland). 2022;9(6)
-
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
Untreated coeliac disease (CeD) can be accompanied by an array of neurological symptoms. Some of these symptoms are similar to those observed in attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD), like an inability to focus, lack of mental alertness, physical under-activity and clinically measurable under-activity in particular brain regions. The mechanism of such symptoms is not fully understood but is thought to be linked to low-grade inflammation in the brain as a result of permeability in the gut and blood-brain barrier, which could contribute to the presentation of ADHD-like symptoms. CeD can persist for many years in seemingly healthy people (silent CeD) without gut symptoms. In this period, ADHD-like symptoms are particularly common and may be treatment resistant if not accompanied by a gluten-free diet Since 2015, there have been several studies showing an association between CeD and ADHD. This is an updated systematic review including 23 studies of children and young adults, which found an association between ADHD and CeD, in contrast to previous reviews that found no clear association. This review paid particular attention to the diagnostic criteria of ADHD and its subtypes, highlighting the need to examine the subtypes of ADHD in future studies. Specifically, the inattentive subtype may be a behavioural ADHD phenotype that could respond to a gluten-free diet. The authors advocate screening ADHD patients for CeD and encourage the consideration of non-neurological symptoms in the assessment of ADHD to identify potential CeD cases.
Expert Review
Conflicts of interest:
None
Take Home Message:
- There is an association between celiac disease (CeD) and attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD).
- Some children with ADHD may respond well to gluten-free diet.
Evidence Category:
-
A: Meta-analyses, position-stands, randomized-controlled trials (RCTs)
-
X
B: Systematic reviews including RCTs of limited number
-
C: Non-randomized trials, observational studies, narrative reviews
-
D: Case-reports, evidence-based clinical findings
-
E: Opinion piece, other
Summary Review:
This systematic review explored the association between coeliac disease (CeD) and attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD).
Methods
The review was conducted following the PRISMA reporting guidelines.
Inclusion criteria for the search:
- Search terms of ADHD and CeD
- Participants < 18 years.
52 papers were retrieved and screened
23 met inclusion/exclusion criteria
Results
- 13 studies (out of the 23) demonstrated an association between ADHD and CeD
- Most studies reporting a positive association were published post 2015
- The largest study reported (112,240 patients with CeD) demonstrates that ADHD showed an association of OR = 1.75 in in CeD.
- The study was limited by several factors including study design of the studies included in the review, which were mostly observational and some without control.
The author declares no conflict of interest.
Clinical practice applications:
- Evidence from across the literature suggests that children with untreated or newly diagnosed CeD may find that following a gluten-free diet can help improve some symptoms associated with ADHD
- The author suggests that there may be a behavioural phenotype of ADHD that responds to a gluten-free diet. If this is the case, it suggests that screening of ADHD patients for celiac disease may be important.
Considerations for future research:
- The number of studies were relatively small and varied in design. Further large-scale studies would help further inform the understanding of the association and potential therapeutic benefits of gluten-free diet.
- It would be interesting to further explore how different subtypes of ADHD, especially the inattentive subtype, may be associated with CeD.
- In particular, it might be useful to consider how the clinical construct of sluggish cognitive tempo (SCT) is associated, since SCT symptoms overlap with the neurological manifestations of CeD.
Abstract
UNLABELLED Controversy around the association between celiac disease (CeD) and attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD) was addressed by a systematic review in 2015, ultimately showing no association. Since 2015, there have been several studies showing an association between celiac disease and attention deficit hyperactive disorder. This is an updated systematic review. BACKGROUND Most experts agree on the recommendation to not screen as part of the standard of care for ADHD in persons with CeD or vice versa. Simultaneously, they propose that untreated patients with CeD and neurological symptoms such as chronic fatigue, inattention, pain, and headache could be predisposed to ADHD-like behavior, namely inattention (which may be alleviated by following a gluten-free diet). The inattentive subtype of ADHD that encompasses the symptoms of inattention is phenotypically heterogeneous, as it includes the clinical construct of sluggish cognitive tempo (SCT). SCT symptoms overlap with the neurological manifestations of CeD. METHODS A systematic search (PRISMA) of PubMed, Google Scholar, EMBASE, Web of Science, Stanford Lane, SCOPUS, and Ovid was conducted for articles up to 21 February 2022. Of these, 23 studies met the criteria. RESULTS Out of the 23 studies, 13 showed a positive association between ADHD and CeD. Most studies that showed a positive association had been published in the last five years. Inconsistencies in the results remain due to the heterogeneous methodology used, specifically for ADHD and the outcome questionnaires, as well as a lack of reporting on ADHD subtypes. CONCLUSION There is an association between ADHD and celiac disease. The current methodological limitations will be lessened if we examine the subtypes of ADHD.
-
4.
Organic food consumption and gluten-free diet, is there a link? Results in French adults without coeliac disease.
Perrin, L, Allès, B, Julia, C, Hercberg, S, Touvier, M, Lairon, D, Baudry, J, Kesse-Guyot, E
The British journal of nutrition. 2021;125(9):1067-1078
-
-
-
Free full text
-
Plain language summary
The gluten-free diet (GFD) is a medical response for people with coeliac disease, a systemic autoimmune disorder for which GFD is the only available effective treatment. The aim of this study was to compare the consumption of organic products (as a whole and by food group) in individuals (partially or totally) avoiding gluten or not, and their places of food purchases of organic food. Results indicate a positive association between gluten avoidance and contribution of organic food to the diet. A gradient was also observed with total avoiders consuming more of organic food than partial avoiders. This contribution was higher for all types of products, except milk and dairy products. Furthermore, the results appear consistent with the motives reported by individuals avoiding gluten. Authors conclude that their findings underline a strong positive correlation between gluten avoidance and organic food consumption.
Abstract
The rising popular belief that gluten is unhealthy has led to growth in gluten avoidance in people without coeliac disease. Little information is available on their dietary profiles and their dietary behaviours. Our aim was to compare the consumption of organic foods between gluten avoiders and non-avoiders, and their places of food purchase. We described their sociodemographic and dietary profiles. The study population included participants of the NutriNet-Santé cohort who completed both a food exclusion questionnaire and an organic semi-quantitative FFQ (n 23 468). Food intake and organic food consumption ratios were compared using multivariable adjusted ANCOVA models. Associations between gluten avoidance and organic food consumption as well as places of food purchase were investigated with multivariable logistic regression. Participants avoiding gluten were more likely to be women and had a healthier dietary profile. Organic food consumption was higher among gluten avoiders (48·50 % of total diet for total avoiders, 17·38 % for non-avoiders). After adjustments for confounders, organic food consumption and purchase in organic stores were positively associated with gluten avoidance: adjusted OR (aOR)Q5 v.Q1 organic food = 4·95; 95 % CI 3·70, 6·63 and aORorganic stores v.supermarkets = 1·82; 95 % CI 1·42, 2·33 for total avoiders. Our study highlights that individuals avoiding gluten are high organic consumers and frequently purchase their foods in organic stores which propose an extended offer of gluten-free food. Further research is needed to determine the underlying common motivations and the temporality of the dietary behaviours of healthy people avoiding gluten.
-
5.
Celiac Disease, Beyond the Bowel: A Review of Its Neurological Manifestations.
Patel, SC, Shreya, D, Zamora, DI, Patel, GS, Grossmann, I, Rodriguez, K, Soni, M, Joshi, PK, Sange, I
Cureus. 2021;13(12):e20112
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
Coeliac disease (CD) is an autoimmune condition in which genetically predisposed individuals develop an immunologic reaction to ingested gluten, a protein found in barley, wheat, and rye, destroying the intestinal villi. The aims of this review are to: (i) underline the pathogenic mechanism of the involvement of CD and its neurological manifestations; (ii) establish a clinical relationship between CD and its neurological manifestations; (iii) explore the existing screening and upcoming management guidelines of CD. This review shows that: - the most common neurological manifestations of CD include gluten ataxia, gluten neuropathy, and epilepsy. These conditions are strongly associated with a lower quality of life and a higher rate of hospitalisation. - neurological features of CD should be kept in mind in order to raise an adequate amount of clinical suspicion to perform screening for gluten sensitivity with the aim of reducing the time it takes for diagnosis, and thus patient suffering is kept to a minimum. Authors conclude that further thorough studies about neurological manifestations of CD are needed so that alternative treatment modalities are offered to provide a more holistic treatment approach to a patient with CD.
Abstract
Celiac disease (CD) is a multi-systemic autoimmune condition that causes a hyperinflammatory response when gluten is ingested. There has been a shift in the clinical presentation of CD from a mere malabsorption disorder to an autoimmune condition that affects multiple organ systems, which could increase the rate of hospitalizations and a decreased quality of life. This article has compiled various studies that have explored the neurological manifestations of celiac disease, their epidemiology, possible pathogenic mechanisms, diagnosis, and treatment. The most common neurological conditions include gluten ataxia (GA), gluten neuropathy, gluten encephalopathy, and epilepsy which usually present as sporadic diseases which are difficult to diagnose in the absence of gastrointestinal (GI) symptoms. The treatment for most of these conditions is a gluten-free diet (GFD) regardless of GI involvement.
-
6.
The Influence of Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth in Digestive and Extra-Intestinal Disorders.
Losurdo, G, Salvatore D'Abramo, F, Indellicati, G, Lillo, C, Ierardi, E, Di Leo, A
International journal of molecular sciences. 2020;21(10)
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
The importance of the gut microbiome in health and disease is a rapidly growing area of research. Small intestinal bacterial overgrowth (SIBO) is a condition in which bacteria that typically exists only in the colon becomes concentrated in the small intestine. SIBO has wide-ranging clinical implications and the aim of this study was to review the current research to assess existing links between SIBO and various diseases. Examining the current literature, the authors found SIBO may be involved in several diseases. SIBO was found to be strongly associated with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS). While the link between SIBO and celiac disease has been studied extensively, findings remain inconsistent. Additionally, SIBO was found to be a potential underlying factor in hepatic encephalopathy. Based on these findings, the authors conclude the scientific hypotheses and the clinical findings are not consistent. While it is widely accepted that alterations in the gut microbiota can influence disease, there is not enough clinical evidence to draw conclusions. The authors conclude the evidence is promising but future research is needed.
Abstract
Small intestinal bacterial overgrowth (SIBO) is a condition hallmarked by an increase in the concentration of colonic-type bacteria in the small bowel. Watery diarrhea, bloating, abdominal pain and distension are the most common clinical manifestations. Additionally, malnutrition and vitamin (B12, D, A, and E) as well as minerals (iron and calcium) deficiency may be present. SIBO may mask or worsen the history of some diseases (celiac disease, irritable bowel disease), may be more common in some extra-intestinal disorders (scleroderma, obesity), or could even represent a pathogenetic link with some diseases, in which a perturbation of intestinal microbiota may be involved. On these bases, we performed a review to explore the multiple links between SIBO and digestive and extra-intestinal diseases.
-
7.
The Neuropathology of Gluten-Related Neurological Disorders: A Systematic Review.
Rouvroye, MD, Zis, P, Van Dam, AM, Rozemuller, AJM, Bouma, G, Hadjivassiliou, M
Nutrients. 2020;12(3)
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
Coeliac disease (CD) is an autoimmune disorder triggered by the ingestion of gluten in genetically susceptible individuals. A wide range of extraintestinal manifestations has been attributed to CD, changing the classic perception of a disease limited to the intestine, to a multisystem disorder. The aim of this study was to analyse the published neuropathology of confirmed cases of gluten-related neurological dysfunction to aid our understanding of the pathogenesis. CD can therefore manifest with dental problems, consequences of malabsorption, skin and neurological disorders. This study is a systematic review of thirty-two neurological disorder focused studies. Results show that: - the neuropathological findings in gluten-related neurological disorders are widespread and not limited to the cerebellum. - the pathology is immune mediated and not related to vitamin or trace elements deficiencies. - the pathophysiology of neurological damage in the context of gluten sensitivity has an immune mediated basis. - more gluten-related neurological disorders affected men (57%), which was even higher in the ataxia group (76%). - transglutaminase 6 antibodies might be helpful in the diagnostic workup of gluten-related neurological disorders. Authors conclude that the current evidence is suggestive of both humoral and cell-mediated immunological responses. Further research is required to investigate the underlying neuropathological mechanism by characterisation of the inflammatory cell infiltrate and identification of target epitopes.
Abstract
Gluten-related neurological disorders (GRND) represent a spectrum of neurological manifestations that are triggered by gluten. In coeliac disease, a T-cell mediated enteropathy is triggered by gluten in genetically predisposed individuals. The underlying pathological mechanism of the neurological dysfunction is not yet clear. The aim of this review is to collate existing neuropathological findings in GRND as a means of aiding the understanding of the pathophysiology. A systematic search of the Pubmed Database yielded 188 articles, of which 32 were included, containing 98 eligible cases with a description of pathological findings in GRND. In gluten ataxia, loss of Purkinje cells, atrophy, gliosis and astrocytosis were apparent, as well as diffuse lymphocytic infiltration and perivascular cuffing with lymphocytes. In patients with large-fiber neuropathy, nerve biopsies revealed axonopathy, loss of myelinated fibers and focal and perivascular infiltration by inflammatory cells. Inflammatory infiltrate was also observed in muscle in myopathy and in cerebrum of patients with encephalopathy and patients with epilepsy. Such changes were not seen in skin biopsies from patients with small fiber neuropathies. The findings from this systematic review suggest an immune mediated pathogenesis for GRND. Future research should focus on the characterization of the inflammatory cell infiltrates and identifying target epitopes.
-
8.
Another Chicken and Egg Story: Systematic Review on Lichen Planus as a Precursor for Celiac Disease in Adult Population.
Khan, S, Patel, S, M, S, Hamid, P
Cureus. 2020;12(8):e9526
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
Lichen planus is a rare, chronic, inflammatory skin condition affecting the mucous membranes. It is immunological, sometimes regarded as autoimmune, and associated with some autoimmune disorders and infectious diseases. The presence of an autoimmune disorder increases the likelihood of the co-occurrence or development of other autoimmune conditions, and such is the case in Coeliac disease (CD). CD is an autoimmune condition leading to damage to the gastrointestinal tissue. CD can remain undetected in many patients, yet skin manifestations can occur long before or together with gastrointestinal damage. Hence the authors of this study were interested in how CD and Lichen planus related to each other and whether Lichen planus can be an early marker for CD. For this 2389 studies were assessed, with the inclusion of nine in the final assessment - a mix of case reports, observational studies, and systematic and traditional reviews. The authors could identify a correlation between lichen planus and CD but could not establish causation or a clear relationship between the two conditions. In conclusion, the authors advocated for more studies on larger population groups. Of clinical interest is the author's suggestion that in LP patients with signs of mouth ulcers and skin eruptions testing for CD and a gluten-free diet is warranted and could help manage disease progression.
Abstract
Celiac disease is receiving much attention due to the gluten-free diet trend. Many health-conscious individuals practice a gluten-free diet, even if they do not have celiac disease. As it is an autoimmune disorder, it is associated with many other autoimmune diseases. We were interested in one skin condition, another autoimmune disorder lichen planus as a correlative factor for celiac disease. The following systematic review may give some clues. We searched online resources including PubMed, PubMed Central, Cochrane library, and Google scholar for systematic reviews, traditional reviews, randomized controlled trials, and meta-analysis on celiac disease and lichen planus. We included human studies published in peer-reviewed journals in the English language. After reviewing 2389 initial results of our search, we excluded 1250 duplicates, 1108 abstracts, 42 irrelevant articles. We assessed the remaining 26 articles for their quality using various quality assessment tools. After the quality assessment, we included nine final articles in our systematic review. Out of these nine studies, there were four systematic reviews, one traditional review, two case reports, and two observational studies. Only two articles had exclusively studied the specific association between celiac and lichen planus. The remaining studies included data that gave an overall association between other skin manifestations of celiac disease. From our study, we could not establish the relationship between celiac disease and lichen planus. We need more case-control studies and clinical trials with a larger population to get conclusive data. From current data, we can conclude that both immunological processes correlate but there is no causation. There is also a need for clinical trials to explore the exacerbation of lichen planus due to celiac disease.
-
9.
Celiac Disease and the Microbiome.
Valitutti, F, Cucchiara, S, Fasano, A
Nutrients. 2019;11(10)
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
Increasing evidence supports the hypothesis that changes in the intestinal microbiome is associated with various chronic diseases, including coeliac disease (CD). While it is known gluten consumption is one trigger for the onset of CD, other contributing factors remain largely unknown. The aim of this review was to summarize the current evidence on the relationship between the intestinal microbiome and CD. Based on the literature reviewed, the authors conclude though gut microbiome is suggested to be a trigger for the onset of CD, the current evidence is mixed. There is currently a multi-center prospective longitudinal study being done on celiac disease and the microbiome and the results from this are eagerly awaited.
Abstract
Growing evidence supports the hypothesis that changes in both the composition and function of the intestinal microbiome are associated with a number of chronic inflammatory diseases including celiac disease (CD). One of the major advances in the field of microbiome studies over the last few decades has been the development of culture-independent approaches to identify and quantify the components of the human microbiota. The study of nucleic acids DNA and RNA found in feces or other biological samples bypasses the need for tissue cultures and also allows the characterization of non-cultivable microbes. Current evidence on the composition of the intestinal microbiome and its role as a causative trigger for CD is highly heterogeneous and sometimes contradictory. This review is aimed at summarizing both pre-clinical (basic science data) and clinical (cross-sectional and prospective studies) evidence addressing the relationship between the intestinal microbiome and CD.
-
10.
Prevalence of osteoporosis and osteopenia in men and premenopausal women with celiac disease: a systematic review.
Ganji, R, Moghbeli, M, Sadeghi, R, Bayat, G, Ganji, A
Nutrition journal. 2019;18(1):9
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
Coeliac disease (CD) is an autoimmune disorder and is known to be associated with a decrease in bone mineral density (BMD). Findings suggest 40-70% of patients with coeliac disease (CD) have low BMD, however this prevalence has been reported without considering confounding variables, such as age, menopause status, lifestyle factors and co-morbidities. The purpose of this review was to show the prevalence of osteoporosis and osteopenia in men and premenopausal women with coeliac disease (CD). This systematic review included 19 studies representing 563 subjects. Based on the current literature the pooled prevalence of osteoporosis was 14.4% and osteopenia was 39.6%. According to these results, the authors conclude bone loss is more prevalent in those with CD however larger case-controlled studies are required to adjust for confounding factors.
Abstract
BACKGROUND Celiac disease (CD) is known as a reason of metabolic osteopathy. Progression of non-invasive methods such as bone densitometry has shown that an important ratio of CD cases is faced with impaired bone mass and such cases are prone to bone fractures. Variety of low bone mineral density in CD is probably because of ignored confounding factors such as age, menopause, and drug. The aim of our study was to systematically review the osteoporosis and osteopenia incidences among premenopausal females and males with CD. METHODS This systematic review was done based on preferred reporting items for systematic reviews (PRISMA) guidelines. PubMed and Scopus and Cochran databases were searched according to the relevant medical subject headings (MeSH) of CD and bone mineral density until 2018. Prevalence of osteopenia and osteoporosis were used as effect size for meta-analysis. Cochrane Q (p < 0.05) and I2 index were presented to reveal the heterogeneity. RESULTS 54 eligible full text reviews were included and nineteen selected for data extraction. Eleven articles didn't have our inclusion criteria and had ignored confounding factors like age and menopause, and we excluded; data extraction was done in eight studies. A total of 563 premenopausal women and men who were from, UK, Brazil, India, Hungary, and Poland were included. The pooled prevalence of osteoporosis was 14.4% [95%CI: 9-20.5%] (Cochrane Q = 7.889, p = 0.96, I2 = 49.29%), and osteopenia was 39.6% [31.1-48.8%] (Cochrane Q = 14.24, p = 0.07, I2 = 71.92%), respectively. CONCLUSION Our findings suggest that bone loss is more prevalent in celiac disease and can be associated with increased risk of fracture. However, but results are pooled prevalence and we need more case -control studies with more sample size and consideration of confounding factors.