1.
Australian women's understanding of menopause and its consequences: a qualitative study.
Herbert, D, Bell, RJ, Young, K, Brown, H, Coles, JY, Davis, SR
Climacteric : the journal of the International Menopause Society. 2020;23(6):622-628
Abstract
BACKGROUND This study was undertaken to determine women's knowledge of menopause and its consequences, and their menopause-related health-care experiences. METHODS Participants were recruited to this cross-sectional qualitative study from a nationally, representative sample of Australian women. Recruitment was stratified by age to achieve groups of premenopausal (PRE), perimenopausal (PERI), early postmenopausal (E-POST), and late postmenopausal (L-POST) women. RESULTS The 32 participants were aged 46-69 years: 10 PRE, three PERI, 11 E-POST and eight L-POST women. All understood that menopause meant the end of reproductive function and were aware of menopause-associated symptoms. Most PRE and E-POST women referred to lifestyle changes to optimize health, and self-help and complementary therapies to manage symptoms. E-POST and L-POST women were more likely to nominate seeing a doctor for overall health and symptom management. Menopausal hormone therapy (MHT) was viewed negatively, with shared perceptions of cancer risk and over-prescription. A strong theme was lack of knowledge of long-term menopause sequelae, with only four women nominating osteoporosis. CONCLUSIONS Our in-depth qualitative study would suggest that, while Australian midlife women have a good understanding of the immediate effects of menopause, their lack of knowledge of the long-term consequences is concerning. Despite the effectiveness and safety of MHT, the overall attitude to MHT remains negative.
2.
Being 'fat' in today's world: a qualitative study of the lived experiences of people with obesity in Australia.
Thomas, SL, Hyde, J, Karunaratne, A, Herbert, D, Komesaroff, PA
Health expectations : an international journal of public participation in health care and health policy. 2008;11(4):321-30
-
-
-
Free full text
-
Plain language summary
The obesity epidemic is one of the most pressing contemporary public health problems. The aim of this study was to develop a picture of both lived experiences of obesity and the impact of socio-cultural factors on obesity. The study adopted a qualitative research design (n=76) . A broad interview schedule was developed by the authors aimed at individuals from a broad range of backgrounds and experiences of obesity. Results indicate that: (a) the experiences of obesity are diverse but there are common themes. (b) people living with obesity have heard the messages but find it difficult to act upon them. (c) interventions should be tailored to address both individual and community needs. (d) there should be a different approach towards obesity interventions. Authors conclude that interventions should respond directly to the social and cultural dimensions of communities and clusters of individuals.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE To develop an in-depth picture of both lived experience of obesity and the impact of socio-cultural factors on people living with obesity. DESIGN Qualitative methodology, utilizing in-depth semi-structured interviews with a community sample of obese adults (body mass index >or=30). Community sampling methods were supplemented with purposive sampling techniques to ensure a diverse range of individuals were included. RESULTS Seventy-six individuals (aged 16-72) were interviewed. Most had struggled with their weight for most of their lives (n=45). Almost all had experienced stigma and discrimination in childhood (n=36), as adolescents (n=41) or as adults (n=72). About half stated that they had been humiliated by health professionals because of their weight. Participants felt an individual responsibility to lose weight, and many tried extreme forms of dieting to do so. Participants described an increasing culture of 'blame' against people living with obesity perpetuated by media and public health messages. Eighty percent said that they hated or disliked the word obesity and would rather be called fat or overweight. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION There are four key conclusions: (i) the experiences of obesity are diverse, but there are common themes, (ii) people living with obesity have heard the messages but find it difficult to act upon them, (iii) interventions should be tailored to address both individual and community needs and (iv) we need to rethink how to approach obesity interventions to ensure that avoid recapitulating damaging social stereotypes and exacerbating social inequalities.