-
1.
Longitudinal association of dietary carbohydrate quality with visceral fat deposition and other adiposity indicators.
Zamanillo-Campos, R, Chaplin, A, Romaguera, D, Abete, I, Salas-Salvadó, J, Martín, V, Estruch, R, Vidal, J, Ruiz-Canela, M, Babio, N, et al
Clinical nutrition (Edinburgh, Scotland). 2022;41(10):2264-2274
-
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
Abdominal obesity, measured by waist circumference, a proxy of visceral fat, is increasing at an even greater rate than overall obesity alone. Diet plays a key role in body fat accumulation; however, recent evidence also indicates that, beyond quantity, the quality of certain nutrients may have an independent effect. The aim of this study was to determine the dynamic association between changes in overall dietary carbohydrate quality and changes in objectively measured visceral and overall adiposity distribution This study is a prospective cohort study based on data collected during the first year of the PREDIMED-Plus (PREvencion con DIeta MEDiterranea Plus) randomised controlled trial. In the PREDIMED-Plus trial, a total of 6874 people were randomly allocated in a 1:1 ratio to either the intervention or control group. Results show that a carbohydrate quality index increase was associated with a decrease in regional and overall adiposity. The observed associations were mostly driven by fibre and the wholegrains/total grains ratio. Authors conclude that the promotion of fibre-rich foods, including fruits, vegetables, legumes and nuts, and the substitution of refined grains by wholegrains, may be important dietary recommendations to adopt in clinical practice to promote a healthier body composition.
Expert Review
Conflicts of interest:
None
Take Home Message:
This prospective cohort of older adults with overweight/obesity and MetS, found that improvements in dietary carbohydrate quality over one year was associated with positive changes in visceral and overall fat deposition, largely due to dietary fibre and the wholegrain/total grain ratio.
Evidence Category:
-
A: Meta-analyses, position-stands, randomized-controlled trials (RCTs)
-
B: Systematic reviews including RCTs of limited number
-
X
C: Non-randomized trials, observational studies, narrative reviews
-
D: Case-reports, evidence-based clinical findings
-
E: Opinion piece, other
Summary Review:
Background
Obesity prevalence is increasing worldwide and is associated with a range of metabolic and cardiovascular diseases. Excess visceral fat appears with increasing age but also with unhealthy dietary patterns and lifestyle behaviours, and it contributes to chronic diseases, particularly type 2 diabetes (T2D), insulin resistance, metabolic syndrome (MetS), and cardiovascular diseases (CVD).
Aim
This study determined the association between changes in overall dietary carbohydrate quality and changes in objectively-measured visceral and overall adiposity distribution. Three repeated measurements of diet and adiposity were conducted throughout a 1-year follow-up, using a dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) scans for body composition assessment.
The study compared an intensive weight-loss (intervention group) using an energy-reduced Mediterranean Diet (MedDiet), with physical activity (PA), and behavioural support on the prevention of CVD events, compared to usual care and dietary counselling only.
This prospective cohort study analysed a subgroup of 1476 participants (men aged 55-75 years and women aged 60-75 years) enrolled in the PREDIMED-Plus randomized controlled trial. Participants were overweight or obese (BMI>27 kg/m2 and <40 kg/m2) with no previous cardiovascular events and at least three characteristics of metabolic syndrome (MetS): hypertension, hyper-triglyceridemia, lower high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol, hyperglycemia, or central obesity.
Dietary intake was measured at baseline, 6- and 12-months using a Spanish version of the validated 143-item semi-quantitative food-frequency questionnaire, via face-to-face interviews by trained dietitian-nutritionists. Carbohydrate quality index (CQI) was calculated using four criteria: total dietary fibre, glycemic index, wholegrain/total grain carbohydrate ratio, and solid/total carbohydrate ratio.
Results
Improvements in body composition and lifestyle factors were observed compared to baseline data (both study arms combined) (p < 0.05 for all). A higher Carbohydrate Quality Index CQI (p = 0.024) was observed at both the 6 and 12 month follow-up.
A 3-point increment in CQI over 12-month follow-up was associated with a decrease in visceral fat (β 0.067 z-score, 95% CI -0.088 to -0.046, p<0.001), android-to-gynoid fat ratio* (β -0.038, 95% CI -0.059 to -0.017, p<0.001) (*calculated by dividing the fat mass (g) from the specific regions), and total fat (β -0.064, 95% CI -0.080 to -0.047, p<0.001).
Fibre intake and the ratio of whole grain/total grain showed the strongest inverse associations with all adiposity indicators. Statistically significant differences were observed over time in all CQI components. The most relevant changes were the increase in consumption of carbohydrates from whole-grains and a decrease in refined grains, and an increase in dietary fibre intake. After evaluating each CQI component separately, the study found that fibre intake and the ratio of whole grain/total grain presented the strongest and statistically significant negative associations with all adiposity indicators (all p-values <0.01).
Limitations
Due to the observational nature of the study, causality cannot be inferred. The study population is based on older people with overweight/obesity and MetS from a Mediterranean area, which can limit the generalisability of findings to the general population.
The use of self-reported dietary data is subject to measurement error, where self-reports may be affected by a tendency to respond in a manner to avoid criticism or judgement and to seek social approval.
Clinical practice applications:
Evidence has shown that the quality of dietary carbohydrates, rather than the quantity, may have a greater impact on health and overall mortality.
While visceral fat constitutes only a small proportion of total fat, the available evidence indicates that it plays an important role in certain chronic diseases, such as T2D, MetS, CVD and cancer.
Findings from this study suggest a better CQI via the manipulation of carbohydrate quality may be associated with a decrease in visceral fat, which are independent of changes in total body fat.
Considerations for future research:
Future strategies to decrease visceral fat are warranted.
Robust reference ranges are needed for the interpretation of visceral fat in clinical practice and research settings.
Abstract
BACKGROUND & AIMS The quality of dietary carbohydrates rather than total carbohydrate intake may determine the accumulation of visceral fat; however, to date, few studies have examined the impact of diet on adiposity using specific imaging techniques. Thus, the aim of this prospective study was to investigate the association between concurrent changes in carbohydrate quality index (CQI) and objectively-quantified adiposity distribution over a year. METHODS We analyzed a cohort of 1476 participants aged 55-75 years with overweight/obesity and metabolic syndrome (MetS) from the PREDIMED-Plus randomized controlled trial. Dietary intake information was obtained at baseline, 6- and 12-months from a validated 143-item semi-quantitative food-frequency questionnaire, and CQI (range: 4 to 20) was calculated based on four dietary criteria: total dietary fibre, glycemic index, wholegrain/total grain carbohydrate ratio, and solid/total carbohydrate ratio. Overall and regional adiposity (total body fat, visceral fat and android-to-gynoid fat ratio) was quantified using dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry at all three time points. Multiple adjusted linear mixed-effects models were used to assess associations between concurrent changes in repeatedly measured CQI and adiposity over time. RESULTS After controlling for potential confounding factors, a 3-point increment in CQI over 12-month follow-up was associated with a decrease in visceral fat (β -0.067 z-score, 95% CI -0.088; -0.046, p < 0.001), android-to-gynoid fat ratio (-0.038, -0.059; -0.017, p < 0.001), and total fat (-0.064, -0.080; -0.047, p < 0.001). Fibre intake and the ratio of wholegrain/total grain showed the strongest inverse associations with all adiposity indicators. CONCLUSIONS In this prospective cohort of older adults with overweight/obesity and MetS, we found that improvements in dietary carbohydrate quality over a year were associated with concurrent favorable changes in visceral and overall fat deposition. These associations were mostly driven by dietary fibre and the wholegrain/total grain ratio. TRIAL REGISTRATION The trial was registered at the International Standard Randomized. CONTROLLED TRIAL (ISRCTN http://www.isrctn.com/ISRCTN89898870) with number 89898870 and registration date of 24 July 2014, retrospectively registered.
-
2.
The effect of a short-term low-carbohydrate, high-fat diet with or without postmeal walks on glycemic control and inflammation in type 2 diabetes: a randomized trial.
Myette-Côté, É, Durrer, C, Neudorf, H, Bammert, TD, Botezelli, JD, Johnson, JD, DeSouza, CA, Little, JP
American journal of physiology. Regulatory, integrative and comparative physiology. 2018;315(6):R1210-R1219
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
Inflammation is associated with the pathogenesis of insulin resistance, type 2 diabetes (T2D), and related complications. Lifestyle therapy is a frontline treatment for improving glucose control in people with T2D. The main aim of this study was to determine whether reducing hyperglycaemia with a low-carbohydrate high-fat (LC) diet could lower markers of innate immune cell activation and systemic inflammation in people with T2D. A secondary aim was to examine if the combination of an LCHF diet with strategically timed postmeal walking was superior to an LCHF diet alone. The study is a randomised cross over study which enrolled Individuals with physician-diagnosed T2D to complete three short-term controlled-intervention periods. Sixteen participants were enrolled (men = 8 and women = 8) who were aged between 48 and 72 years. Results indicate that while LC and LC together with exercise (LC+Ex) led to superior improvements in glucose control and fasting proinsulin (the pro-hormone precursor to insulin) levels as compared with low-fat low glycaemic index diet (GL), all three diets (GL, LC and LC+Ex), appeared to lower a particular marker of cellular inflammation over the short-term. Authors conclude that an LCHF diet with or without daily postmeal walks improved four-day glycaemic control and fasting proinsulin levels compared with a GL diet.
Abstract
Lowering carbohydrate consumption effectively lowers glucose, but impacts on inflammation are unclear. The objectives of this study were to: 1) determine whether reducing hyperglycemia by following a low-carbohydrate, high-fat (LC) diet could lower markers of innate immune cell activation in type 2 diabetes (T2D) and 2) examine if the combination of an LC diet with strategically timed postmeal walking was superior to an LC diet alone. Participants with T2D ( n = 11) completed a randomized crossover study involving three 4-day diet interventions: 1) low-fat low-glycemic index (GL), 2) and 3) LC with 15-min postmeal walks (LC+Ex). Four-day mean glucose was significantly lower in the LC+Ex group as compared with LC (-5%, P < 0.05), whereas both LC+Ex (-16%, P < 0.001) and LC (-12%, P < 0.001) conditions were lower than GL. A significant main effect of time was observed for peripheral blood mononuclear cells phosphorylated c-Jun N-terminal kinase ( P < 0.001), with decreases in all three conditions (GL: -32%, LC: -45%, and LC+Ex: -44%). A significant condition by time interaction was observed for monocyte microparticles ( P = 0.040) with a significant decrease in GL (-76%, P = 0.035) and a tendency for a reduction in LC (-70%, P = 0.064), whereas there was no significant change in LC+Ex (0.5%, P = 0.990). Both LC (-27%, P = 0.001) and LC+Ex (-35%, P = 0.005) also led to significant reductions in circulating proinsulin. An LC diet improved 4-day glycemic control and fasting proinsulin levels when compared with GL, with added glucose-lowering benefits when LC was combined with postmeal walking.
-
3.
Circulating bile acids in healthy adults respond differently to a dietary pattern characterized by whole grains, legumes and fruits and vegetables compared to a diet high in refined grains and added sugars: A randomized, controlled, crossover feeding study.
Ginos, BNR, Navarro, SL, Schwarz, Y, Gu, H, Wang, D, Randolph, TW, Shojaie, A, Hullar, MAJ, Lampe, PD, Kratz, M, et al
Metabolism: clinical and experimental. 2018;83:197-204
-
-
-
Free full text
-
Plain language summary
Bile acids are produced in the liver and are important for the absorption of fat and fat-soluble vitamins. About 95% of bile acids are reabsorbed. Circulating plasma bile acids can affect glucose metabolism and inflammation, and are thought to play a role in the development of metabolic syndrome. The aim of this study was to evaluate how plasma bile acid levels are influenced by a diet rich in whole grains, legumes, fruit and vegetables (low glycaemic load, GL) compared to a diet high in refined grains and sugar (high GL). The study evaluated data from a previous double-blind randomised, cross over feeding trial. 80 healthy adults had the low or high GL diet for four weeks, and after a four-week washout period, received the other diet for four weeks. Three specific plasma bile acids, which are thought to have a positive impact on glucose metabolism, were higher in the low GL group compared to the high GL group. Some individual plasma bile acids were positively associated with HOMA-IR (a measure of glucose metabolism/insulin resistance). There was no significant association between bile acid concentrations and C-reactive protein (a marker of inflammation). The authors conclude that the increase in certain bile acids on the low GL diet may be beneficial and that this effect may be to some extent mediated by the impact of the higher fibre content of the low GL diet on the gut microbial metabolism, which affects plasma bile acid levels.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE The effects of diets high in refined grains on biliary and colonic bile acids have been investigated extensively. However, the effects of diets high in whole versus refined grains on circulating bile acids, which can influence glucose homeostasis and inflammation through activation of farnesoid X receptor (FXR) and G protein-coupled bile acid receptor 1 (TGR5), have not been studied. MATERIALS AND METHODS We conducted a secondary analysis from a randomized controlled crossover feeding trial (NCT00622661) in 80 healthy adults (40 women/40 men, age 18-45 years) from the greater Seattle Area, half of which were normal weight (BMI 18.5-25.0 kg/m2) and half overweight to obese (BMI 28.0-39.9 kg/m2). Participants consumed two four-week controlled diets in randomized order: 1) a whole grain diet (WG diet), designed to be low in glycemic load (GL), high in whole grains, legumes, and fruits and vegetables, and 2) a refined grain diet (RG diet), designed to be high GL, high in refined grains and added sugars, separated by a four-week washout period. Quantitative targeted analysis of 55 bile acid species in fasting plasma was performed using liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry. Concentrations of glucose, insulin, and CRP were measured in fasting serum. Linear mixed models were used to test the effects of diet on bile acid concentrations, and determine the association between plasma bile acid concentrations and HOMA-IR and CRP. Benjamini-Hochberg false discovery rate (FDR) < 0.05 was used to control for multiple testing. RESULTS A total of 29 plasma bile acids were reliably detected and retained for analysis. Taurolithocholic acid (TLCA), taurocholic acid (TCA) and glycocholic acid (GCA) were statistically significantly higher after the WG compared to the RG diet (FDR < 0.05). There were no significant differences by BMI or sex. When evaluating the association of bile acids and HOMA-IR, GCA, taurochenodeoxycholic acid, ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA), 5β‑cholanic acid‑3β,12α‑diol, 5‑cholanic acid‑3β‑ol, and glycodeoxycholic acid (GDCA) were statistically significantly positively associated with HOMA-IR individually, and as a group, total, 12α‑hydroxylated, primary and secondary bile acids were also significant (FDR < 0.05). When stratifying by BMI, chenodeoxycholic acid (CDCA), cholic acid (CA), UDCA, 5β-cholanic acid-3β, deoxycholic acid, and total, 12α-hydroxylated, primary and secondary bile acid groups were significantly positively associated with HOMA-IR among overweight to obese individuals (FDR < 0.05). When stratifying by sex, GCA, CDCA, TCA, CA, UDCA, GDCA, glycolithocholic acid (GLCA), total, primary, 12α‑hydroxylated, and glycine-conjugated bile acids were significantly associated with HOMA-IR among women, and CDCA, GDCA, and GLCA were significantly associated among men (FDR < 0.05). There were no significant associations between bile acids and CRP. CONCLUSIONS Diets with comparable macronutrient and energy composition, but differing in carbohydrate source, affected fasting plasma bile acids differently. Specifically, a diet characterized by whole grains, legumes, and fruits and vegetables compared to a diet high in refined grains and added sugars led to modest increases in concentrations of TLCA, TCA and GCA, ligands for FXR and TGR5, which may have beneficial effects on glucose homeostasis.
-
4.
Glycemic index, glycemic load, and risk of type 2 diabetes: results from 3 large US cohorts and an updated meta-analysis.
Bhupathiraju, SN, Tobias, DK, Malik, VS, Pan, A, Hruby, A, Manson, JE, Willett, WC, Hu, FB
The American journal of clinical nutrition. 2014;100(1):218-32
-
-
-
Free full text
-
Plain language summary
Carbohydrates are the principle dietary components that effect blood glucose concentrations. The association between Type 2 diabetes (T2D) and diets with different levels of sugars and carbohydrates has been controversial in the prevention of T2D. Foods can be measured for their impact on blood glucose concentration using the Glycaemic Index (GI) and the Glycaemic Load (GL). The objective of this meta-analysis was to update previous studies and evaluate the association between the GI and GL of dietary intake and the risk of T2D. The authors found a significant association between the GI and GL of food intake and T2D risk and conclude that high GI and GL foods increase the risk of T2D. However, GI is more strongly associated to T2D than GL.
Abstract
BACKGROUND Epidemiologic evidence for the relation between carbohydrate quality and risk of type 2 diabetes (T2D) has been mixed. OBJECTIVE We prospectively examined the association of dietary glycemic index (GI) and glycemic load (GL) with T2D risk. DESIGN We prospectively followed 74,248 women from the Nurses' Health Study (1984-2008), 90,411 women from the Nurses' Health Study II (1991-2009), and 40,498 men from the Health Professionals Follow-Up Study (1986-2008) who were free of diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and cancer at baseline. Diet was assessed by using a validated questionnaire and updated every 4 y. We also conducted an updated meta-analysis, including results from our 3 cohorts and other studies. RESULTS During 3,800,618 person-years of follow-up, we documented 15,027 cases of incident T2D. In pooled multivariable analyses, those in the highest quintile of energy-adjusted GI had a 33% higher risk (95% CI: 26%, 41%) of T2D than those in the lowest quintile. Participants in the highest quintile of energy-adjusted GL had a 10% higher risk (95% CI: 2%, 18%) of T2D. Participants who consumed a combination diet that was high in GI or GL and low in cereal fiber had an ~50% higher risk of T2D. In the updated meta-analysis, the summary RRs (95% CIs) comparing the highest with the lowest categories of GI and GL were 1.19 (1.14, 1.24) and 1.13 (1.08, 1.17), respectively. CONCLUSION The updated analyses from our 3 cohorts and meta-analyses provide further evidence that higher dietary GI and GL are associated with increased risk of T2D.
-
5.
Sucralose affects glycemic and hormonal responses to an oral glucose load.
Pepino, MY, Tiemann, CD, Patterson, BW, Wice, BM, Klein, S
Diabetes care. 2013;36(9):2530-5
-
-
-
Free full text
-
Plain language summary
Non-nutritive sweeteners (NNS) are food additives that provide a sweet taste to food but have few, if any, calories. Currently, seven NNS (sucralose, saccharin, aspartame, acesulfame potassium, neotame, stevia, and Luo han guo extract) are approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and are widely used in thousands of food products. The aim of this study was to analyse whether sucralose ingestion alters the glycaemic and hormonal responses to glucose ingestion in obese subjects who are not regular users of NNS. Seventeen participants who were obese but not insulin resistant participated in the study. They were studied on two separate occasions, 7 days apart, in a crossover design. Sucralose was used as it matches the sweetness of a typical diet soda and also stimulates glucagon-like peptide 1 [a type of peptide hormone] secretion. Results demonstrate that: - the ingestion of sucralose alters the metabolic response to an oral glucose load in obese people who are not regular consumers of NNS. - insulin clearance from plasma was slower after sucralose than after water ingestion. - glucose-induced glucagon [hormone that helps control blood sugar levels] suppression was the same after both sucralose and water ingestion Authors conclude that sucralose is not metabolically inert but has physiologic effects.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE Nonnutritive sweeteners (NNS), such as sucralose, have been reported to have metabolic effects in animal models. However, the relevance of these findings to human subjects is not clear. We evaluated the acute effects of sucralose ingestion on the metabolic response to an oral glucose load in obese subjects. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS Seventeen obese subjects (BMI 42.3 ± 1.6 kg/m(2)) who did not use NNS and were insulin sensitive (based on a homeostasis model assessment of insulin resistance score ≤ 2.6) underwent a 5-h modified oral glucose tolerance test on two separate occasions preceded by consuming either sucralose (experimental condition) or water (control condition) 10 min before the glucose load in a randomized crossover design. Indices of β-cell function, insulin sensitivity (SI), and insulin clearance rates were estimated by using minimal models of glucose, insulin, and C-peptide kinetics. RESULTS Compared with the control condition, sucralose ingestion caused 1) a greater incremental increase in peak plasma glucose concentrations (4.2 ± 0.2 vs. 4.8 ± 0.3 mmol/L; P = 0.03), 2) a 20 ± 8% greater incremental increase in insulin area under the curve (AUC) (P < 0.03), 3) a 22 ± 7% greater peak insulin secretion rate (P < 0.02), 4) a 7 ± 4% decrease in insulin clearance (P = 0.04), and 5) a 23 ± 20% decrease in SI (P = 0.01). There were no significant differences between conditions in active glucagon-like peptide 1, glucose-dependent insulinotropic polypeptide, glucagon incremental AUC, or indices of the sensitivity of the β-cell response to glucose. CONCLUSIONS These data demonstrate that sucralose affects the glycemic and insulin responses to an oral glucose load in obese people who do not normally consume NNS.
-
6.
Glycemic load effect on fasting and post-prandial serum glucose, insulin, IGF-1 and IGFBP-3 in a randomized, controlled feeding study.
Runchey, SS, Pollak, MN, Valsta, LM, Coronado, GD, Schwarz, Y, Breymeyer, KL, Wang, C, Wang, CY, Lampe, JW, Neuhouser, ML
European journal of clinical nutrition. 2012;66(10):1146-52
-
-
-
Free full text
-
Plain language summary
Dietary intervention studies have shown detrimental metabolic effects of high-glycaemic load diets. The glycaemic index (GI) is the numerical classification of a particular food’s blood glucose-raising effect. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of a high-glycaemic load diet on circulating levels of insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) [hormone] and insulin-like growth factor-binding protein 3 (IGFBP-3) [protein] compared to a low-glycaemic load diet. The study is a randomised controlled crossover study which enrolled 84 normal weight and overweight-obese healthy individuals. The study included two 28-day weight-maintaining high- and low-glycaemic load diets. Results indicate that consumption of a low-glycaemic load diet resulted in lower post-prandial [after a meal] insulin and glucose responses and modestly lower fasting IGF-1 and IGF-1/IGFBP-3 concentrations. However, there were no observable effects of glycaemic load on insulin resistance or glucose-adjusted post-prandial insulin responses in these healthy participants. Authors conclude that further intervention studies are required in order to weigh the impact of dietary glycaemic load on risk for chronic disease.
Abstract
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES The effect of a low glycemic load (GL) diet on insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) concentration is still unknown but may contribute to lower chronic disease risk. We aimed to assess the impact of GL on concentrations of IGF-1 and IGF-binding protein-3 (IGFBP-3). SUBJECTS/METHODS We conducted a randomized, controlled crossover feeding trial in 84 overweight obese and normal weight healthy individuals using two 28-day weight-maintaining high- and low-GL diets. Measures were fasting and post-prandial concentrations of insulin, glucose, IGF-1 and IGFBP-3. In all 80 participants completed the study and 20 participants completed post-prandial testing by consuming a test breakfast at the end of each feeding period. We used paired t-tests for diet component and linear mixed models for biomarker analyses. RESULTS The 28-day low-GL diet led to 4% lower fasting concentrations of IGF-1 (10.6 ng/ml, P=0.04) and a 4% lower ratio of IGF-1/IGFBP-3 (0.24, P=0.01) compared with the high-GL diet. The low-GL test breakfast led to 43% and 27% lower mean post-prandial glucose and insulin responses, respectively; mean incremental areas under the curve for glucose and insulin, respectively, were 64.3±21.8 (mmol/l/240 min; P<0.01) and 2253±539 (μU/ml/240 min; P<0.01) lower following the low- compared with the high-GL test meal. There was no effect of GL on mean homeostasis model assessment for insulin resistance or on mean integrated post-prandial concentrations of glucose-adjusted insulin, IGF-1 or IGFBP-3. We did not observe modification of the dietary effect by adiposity. CONCLUSIONS Low-GL diets resulted in 43% and 27% lower post-prandial responses of glucose and insulin, respectively, and modestly lower fasting IGF-1 concentrations. Further intervention studies are needed to weigh the impact of dietary GL on risk for chronic disease.
-
7.
Effects of dietary composition on energy expenditure during weight-loss maintenance.
Ebbeling, CB, Swain, JF, Feldman, HA, Wong, WW, Hachey, DL, Garcia-Lago, E, Ludwig, DS
JAMA. 2012;307(24):2627-34
-
-
-
Free full text
-
Plain language summary
Many diets can produce weight loss over the short term, but most people struggle to maintain this loss over the long term. One explanation is that weight loss results in biological effects, such as a decline in energy expenditure and an increase in hunger, that promote weight regain. The aim of the study was to examine the effects of three different diets on energy expenditure, hormones (including leptin, insulin, cortisol and thyroid hormones) and metabolic indicators following a 10-15% weight loss. The three diets differed widely in macronutrient composition and were: low-fat/high glycaemic load (60% energy from carbohydrates, 20%, 20% protein) LF; low glycaemic index (40%-40%-20%) LGI; and very low carbohydrate/low glycaemic load (10%-60%-30%) VLC. Participants were assigned to one of the three diets for four weeks. Participants on the VLC diet had a resting energy expenditure (REE) of 67kcal/day greater than the LF diet, as well as a total energy expenditure (TEE) of 300kcal/day greater. The physiological basis for these differences is unclear. Although the VLC diet produced the greatest improvements in most metabolic syndrome markers, it also resulted in increased cortisol and inflammation markers. These could be deleterious to health in the long term.
Abstract
CONTEXT Reduced energy expenditure following weight loss is thought to contribute to weight gain. However, the effect of dietary composition on energy expenditure during weight-loss maintenance has not been studied. OBJECTIVE To examine the effects of 3 diets differing widely in macronutrient composition and glycemic load on energy expenditure following weight loss. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS A controlled 3-way crossover design involving 21 overweight and obese young adults conducted at Children's Hospital Boston and Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, between June 16, 2006, and June 21, 2010, with recruitment by newspaper advertisements and postings. INTERVENTION After achieving 10% to 15% weight loss while consuming a run-in diet, participants consumed an isocaloric low-fat diet (60% of energy from carbohydrate, 20% from fat, 20% from protein; high glycemic load), low-glycemic index diet (40% from carbohydrate, 40% from fat, and 20% from protein; moderate glycemic load), and very low-carbohydrate diet (10% from carbohydrate, 60% from fat, and 30% from protein; low glycemic load) in random order, each for 4 weeks. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Primary outcome was resting energy expenditure (REE), with secondary outcomes of total energy expenditure (TEE), hormone levels, and metabolic syndrome components. RESULTS Compared with the pre-weight-loss baseline, the decrease in REE was greatest with the low-fat diet (mean [95% CI], -205 [-265 to -144] kcal/d), intermediate with the low-glycemic index diet (-166 [-227 to -106] kcal/d), and least with the very low-carbohydrate diet (-138 [-198 to -77] kcal/d; overall P = .03; P for trend by glycemic load = .009). The decrease in TEE showed a similar pattern (mean [95% CI], -423 [-606 to -239] kcal/d; -297 [-479 to -115] kcal/d; and -97 [-281 to 86] kcal/d, respectively; overall P = .003; P for trend by glycemic load < .001). Hormone levels and metabolic syndrome components also varied during weight maintenance by diet (leptin, P < .001; 24-hour urinary cortisol, P = .005; indexes of peripheral [P = .02] and hepatic [P = .03] insulin sensitivity; high-density lipoprotein [HDL] cholesterol, P < .001; non-HDL cholesterol, P < .001; triglycerides, P < .001; plasminogen activator inhibitor 1, P for trend = .04; and C-reactive protein, P for trend = .05), but no consistent favorable pattern emerged. CONCLUSION Among overweight and obese young adults compared with pre-weight-loss energy expenditure, isocaloric feeding following 10% to 15% weight loss resulted in decreases in REE and TEE that were greatest with the low-fat diet, intermediate with the low-glycemic index diet, and least with the very low-carbohydrate diet. TRIAL REGISTRATION clinicaltrials.gov Identifier: NCT00315354.