1.
The effect of high-polyphenol Mediterranean diet on visceral adiposity: the DIRECT PLUS randomized controlled trial.
Zelicha, H, Kloting, N, Kaplan, A, Yaskolka Meir, A, Rinott, E, Tsaban, G, Chassidim, Y, Bluher, M, Ceglarek, U, Isermann, B, et al
BMC medicine. 2022;20(1):327
-
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
Visceral adipose tissue (VAT) accumulation is one of the main key factors that differentiate between metabolic healthy and unhealthy obese individuals. VAT is closely related to the development of multiple cardiovascular risk factors. The Mediterranean (MED) diet, high in polyphenol content and rich in plant food sources, was shown to have an enhanced effect on VAT reduction in combination with physical activity (PA), regardless of weight loss The aim of this study was to assess the effect of the MED diet, further enriched with polyphenols, and lower in red and processed meat (“green-MED diet”) on visceral adiposity in the 18-month Dietary Intervention Randomized Controlled Trial-Polyphenols, Unprocessed trial. This study is a randomised controlled trial. Participants were randomly assigned to one of three intervention groups (1:1:1 ratio): healthy dietary guidelines, MED diet, or green-MED diet, all included PA recommendations, with a free gym membership and educational sessions promoting moderate-intensity PA. Results show that participants following the green-MED diet achieved more than twice the degree of VAT reduction compared to those following the MED diet, despite similar weight loss. In fact, VAT loss was specifically related to lower red meat intake and increased walnuts, green tea, Wolfa globosa, and dietary fibre (this was reflected by higher plasma polyphenol and serum folate levels). Authors conclude that a green-MED diet enriched with polyphenols and decreased red meat consumption might serve as an improved version of the MED diet for targeted VAT reduction.
Expert Review
Conflicts of interest:
None
Take Home Message:
- The positive health effects of the traditional MED diet, moderately high in PUFAs and MUFAs and low in red meat, are well-established
- Higher levels of total plasma polyphenol and serum folate may reflect higher consumption of “green” dietary components, which were significantly associated with greater VAT loss
- The green-MED diet, richer in dietary polyphenols and green plant-based proteins and lower in red meat, might be a more effective strategy for VAT loss than the traditional healthy MED diet, achieving more than twice the degree of VAT reduction, despite similar weight loss.
- VAT loss was specifically related to lower red meat intake and increased walnuts, green tea, Wolffia globosa, and dietary fibre and was reflected by higher plasma polyphenol and serum folate levels.
Evidence Category:
-
X
A: Meta-analyses, position-stands, randomized-controlled trials (RCTs)
-
B: Systematic reviews including RCTs of limited number
-
C: Non-randomized trials, observational studies, narrative reviews
-
D: Case-reports, evidence-based clinical findings
-
E: Opinion piece, other
Summary Review:
A mediterranean (MED) diet is a rich source of polyphenols, which benefit adiposity by several mechanisms. Visceral adipose tissue (VAT) accumulation is one of the main factors that differentiate between metabolic healthy and unhealthy obese individuals.
In this Dietary Intervention Randomised Controlled Trial PoLyphenols UnproceSsed (DIRECT‐ PLUS) weight‐loss trial, 294 participants were randomised to: (A) healthy dietary guidelines (HDG), (B) MED, or (C) green‐MED diets, all combined with physical activity. The study duration was 18‐months.
This study explored the effect of the green‐MED diet, twice fortified in dietary polyphenols and lower in red/processed meat, on visceral adipose tissue (VAT) and used magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to quantify the abdominal adipose tissues.
Both isocaloric (with the same calorific value) MED groups consumed 28 g/day of walnuts (+ 440 mg/day polyphenols). The green‐MED group further consumed green tea (3–4 cups/day) and Wolffia globosa (duckweed strain) plant green shake (100 g frozen cubes/day) (+ 800mg/day polyphenols) and reduced red meat intake.
The mean weight loss (HDG: −0.4% (5.0), MED: −2.7% (5.6), green-MED: −3.9% (6.5)) and WC loss (HDG: −3.6% (5.1), MED: −4.7% (5.0), green-MED: −5.7%(5.7)) after 18 months were similar between the two MED diets (p > 0.05 for all) and higher as compared to the HDG (weight: HDG vs. MED: p = 0.02; HDG vs. green+MED: p < 0.001; WC: HDG vs. MED: p = 0.33, HDG vs. green+MED: p = 0.02).
All three abdominal fat depots decreased over 18 months of intervention (p < 0.05 vs. baseline for all). The green-MED group achieved a greater reduction in VAT than the other intervention groups (HDG: −4.2% (22.5), MED: −6.0%(31.3), green-MED: −14.1%(27.7); p < 0.05 green-MED vs. MED or vs. HDG groups). These differences in VAT loss across the groups remained significant after adjusting for age, sex, and 18-month WC change (green-MED vs. MED p = 0.023; green-MED vs. HDG p = 0.002) (Fig. 1)
Limitations of the study included a low proportion of women, and different VAT proportions at baseline across groups limit the generalisability of findings to women.
The authors of the study did not identify the exact components responsible for the dietary effects when they compared dietary regimens and not specific nutrients.
Adherence was by a validated, self-reported dietary intake assessment tool, which the authors acknowledge is subject to error
Strengths of the study included the relatively large sample size, high retention rate, and use of 3-T MRI measurements (considered one of the gold standards tools for the quantification of specific fat depots
Clinical practice applications:
- This trial shows that, when combined with a Mediterranean diet, higher dietary consumption of green tea, walnuts, and dietary fibre and reduced red meat consumption were significantly associated with greater %VAT loss
- The authors observed a significant synergistic interaction effect between decreased red meat consumption and increased serum folate on VAT loss
- A reduction in VAT accumulation, known as a key risk factor in CVD development, may reduce metabolic complications, improve the lipid profile, and decrease cardiometabolic risk.
Considerations for future research:
- Future studies are needed to explore the exact mechanisms of specific polyphenol-rich foods on visceral adiposity.
- Future studies could explore whether the results are replicable in both male and female participants, as this sample was largely male.
Abstract
BACKGROUND Mediterranean (MED) diet is a rich source of polyphenols, which benefit adiposity by several mechanisms. We explored the effect of the green-MED diet, twice fortified in dietary polyphenols and lower in red/processed meat, on visceral adipose tissue (VAT). METHODS In the 18-month Dietary Intervention Randomized Controlled Trial PoLyphenols UnproceSsed (DIRECT-PLUS) weight-loss trial, 294 participants were randomized to (A) healthy dietary guidelines (HDG), (B) MED, or (C) green-MED diets, all combined with physical activity. Both isocaloric MED groups consumed 28 g/day of walnuts (+ 440 mg/day polyphenols). The green-MED group further consumed green tea (3-4 cups/day) and Wolffia globosa (duckweed strain) plant green shake (100 g frozen cubes/day) (+ 800mg/day polyphenols) and reduced red meat intake. We used magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to quantify the abdominal adipose tissues. RESULTS Participants (age = 51 years; 88% men; body mass index = 31.2 kg/m2; 29% VAT) had an 89.8% retention rate and 79.3% completed eligible MRIs. While both MED diets reached similar moderate weight (MED: - 2.7%, green-MED: - 3.9%) and waist circumference (MED: - 4.7%, green-MED: - 5.7%) loss, the green-MED dieters doubled the VAT loss (HDG: - 4.2%, MED: - 6.0%, green-MED: - 14.1%; p < 0.05, independent of age, sex, waist circumference, or weight loss). Higher dietary consumption of green tea, walnuts, and Wolffia globosa; lower red meat intake; higher total plasma polyphenols (mainly hippuric acid), and elevated urine urolithin A polyphenol were significantly related to greater VAT loss (p < 0.05, multivariate models). CONCLUSIONS A green-MED diet, enriched with plant-based polyphenols and lower in red/processed meat, may be a potent intervention to promote visceral adiposity regression. TRIAL REGISTRATION ClinicalTrials.gov , NCT03020186.
2.
The effects of phosphocreatine disodium salts plus blueberry extract supplementation on muscular strength, power, and endurance.
Anders, JPV, Neltner, TJ, Smith, RW, Keller, JL, Housh, TJ, Daugherty, FJ, Tempesta, MS, Dash, AK, Munt, DJ, Schmidt, RJ, et al
Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition. 2021;18(1):60
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
The effects of polyphenols and phosphocreatine supplementation on exercise performance, muscular strength, power, and endurance are largely unknown. This randomised, double-blinded, placebo-controlled, parallel-design trial aimed to differentiate the effects of a blend of 5 grams of phosphocreatine disodium salts plus 200 mg blueberry extract (PCDSB), 3 grams of Creatinine monohydrate (CM), and placebo on measures of muscular strength, power, and endurance. PCDSB contained 60 grams of phenols and 2.5 grams of pure creatine, and CM contained 2.4 grams of pure creatin. During this trial, thirty-three men took random supplements for 28 days and kept up their regular exercise regimen. In both PCDSB and CM, Peak torque (PT) and Average power (AP) increased after 28 days of supplementation with no effect on fatigue-induced PT% and AP% or body mass. Additionally, a greater proportion of participants showed a meaningful increase in muscular strength to PCDSB than to CM. To evaluate the additive effects of ingredients in the PCDSB supplement, longer-term studies are needed with larger supplementation doses. The study provides insight into the ergogenic effects of PCDSB and CM for healthcare practitioners.
Abstract
BACKGROUND Numerous studies have demonstrated the efficacy of creatine supplementation for improvements in exercise performance. Few studies, however, have examined the effects of phosphocreatine supplementation on exercise performance. Furthermore, while polyphenols have antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties, little is known regarding the influence of polyphenol supplementation on muscular strength, power, and endurance. Thus, the purpose of the present study was to compare the effects of 28 days of supplementation with phosphocreatine disodium salts plus blueberry extract (PCDSB), creatine monohydrate (CM), and placebo on measures of muscular strength, power, and endurance. METHODS Thirty-three men were randomly assigned to consume either PCDSB, CM, or placebo for 28 days. Peak torque (PT), average power (AP), and percent decline for peak torque (PT%) and average power (AP%) were assessed from a fatigue test consisting of 50 maximal, unilateral, isokinetic leg extensions at 180°·s- 1 before and after the 28 days of supplementation. Individual responses were assessed to examine the proportion of subjects that exceeded a minimal important difference (MID). RESULTS The results demonstrated significant (p < 0.05) improvements in PT for the PCDSB and CM groups from pre- (99.90 ± 22.47 N·m and 99.95 ± 22.50 N·m, respectively) to post-supplementation (119.22 ± 29.87 N·m and 111.97 ± 24.50 N·m, respectively), but no significant (p = 0.112) change for the placebo group. The PCDSB and CM groups also exhibited significant improvements in AP from pre- (140.18 ± 32.08 W and 143.42 ± 33.84 W, respectively) to post-supplementation (170.12 ± 42.68 W and 159.78 ± 31.20 W, respectively), but no significant (p = 0.279) change for the placebo group. A significantly (p < 0.05) greater proportion of subjects in the PCDSB group exceeded the MID for PT compared to the placebo group, but there were no significant (p > 0.05) differences in the proportion of subjects exceeding the MID between the CM and placebo groups or between the CM and PCDSB groups. CONCLUSIONS These findings indicated that for the group mean responses, 28 days of supplementation with both PCDSB and CM resulted in increases in PT and AP. The PCDSB, however, may have an advantage over CM when compared to the placebo group for the proportion of individuals that respond favorably to supplementation with meaningful increases in muscular strength.
3.
Effect of bilberry juice on indices of muscle damage and inflammation in runners completing a half-marathon: a randomised, placebo-controlled trial.
Lynn, A, Garner, S, Nelson, N, Simper, TN, Hall, AC, Ranchordas, MK
Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition. 2018;15:22
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
There is a growing interest in identifying alternative approaches for reducing inflammation and lessening recovery time among long distance runners. This type of exercise causes inflammation and muscle soreness which impacts performance and ability to train. Recent studies have shown that various plant-derived polyphenols can counter exercise-induced inflammation and muscle soreness. The aim of this single blind, randomised, parallel study was to investigate whether supplementation of bilberry juice (BJ), a polyphenol-rich fruit, would reduce inflammation and muscle soreness in 19 runners completing a half marathon. Participants were randomised to consume BJ or a placebo fruit drink for 5 days prior to the half marathon, on the day of the race and for two days after the race. Blood samples were collected at baseline, pre-race, post-race, 1 day post-race and 2 days post-race and markers of muscle soreness and damage were measured. Contrary to hypothesis, this study found evidence that BJ produced possibly harmful effects on muscle soreness and inflammatory markers compared to placebo. Based on these results, the authors recommend a larger study to confirm the findings and further explore the underlying cause of the observed detrimental changes.
Abstract
BACKGROUND Emerging evidence indicates that fruits rich in polyphenols may attenuate exercise-induced muscle damage and associated markers of inflammation and soreness. This study was conducted to determine whether bilberry juice (BJ), which is particularly rich in polyphenols, reduces markers of muscle damage in runners completing a half marathon. METHODS A total of 21 recreationally trained runners (age 30.9 ± 10.4 y; mass 71.6 ± 11.0 kg; M = 16; F = 5) were recruited to a single blind, randomised, placebo-controlled, parallel study. Participants were block randomised to consume 2 × 200 ml of BJ or energy-matched control drink (PLA) for 5 d before the Sheffield Half Marathon, on race day, and for 2 days post-race. Measurements of delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS), muscle damage (creatine kinase; CK) and inflammation (c-reactive protein; CRP) were taken at baseline, pre-race, post-race, 24 h post-race and 48 h post-race. The effect of treatment on outcome measures was analysed using magnitude-based inferences based on data from 19 participants; 2 participants were excluded from the analyses because they did not provide samples for all time points. RESULTS The half marathon caused elevations in DOMS, CRP and CK. BJ had a possibly harmful effect on DOMS from pre-race to immediately post-race (11.6%, 90% CI ± 14.7%), a likely harmful effect on CRP from pre-race to 24 h post-race (mean difference ES 0.56, 90% CI ± 0.72) and a possibly harmful effect on CRP from pre-race to 48 h post-race (ES 0.12, 90% CI ± 0.69). At other time points, the differences between the BJ and PLA groups in DOMS and CRP were unclear, possibly trivial or likely trivial. Differences in the changes in CK between BJ and PLA were unclear at every time point other than from baseline to pre-race, where BJ had a possibly harmful effect on reducing muscle damage (ES 0.23, 90% CI ± 0.57). CONCLUSION Despite being a rich source of antioxidant and anti-inflammatory phytochemicals, BJ evoked small to moderate increases in exercise-induced DOMS and CRP. Further larger studies are required to confirm these unexpected preliminary results.
4.
The effect of green tea extract supplementation on exercise-induced oxidative stress parameters in male sprinters.
Jówko, E, Długołęcka, B, Makaruk, B, Cieśliński, I
European journal of nutrition. 2015;54(5):783-91
-
-
-
Free full text
-
Plain language summary
High intensity exercise generates reactive oxygen species (ROS), which help with muscle recovery. However, when produced in excess, ROSs cause oxidative stress and cellular damage. Antioxidants produced in the body or taken in through the diet are able to make ROSs inactive. This double blind, randomised controlled trial aimed to evaluate the effects of Green tea extract supplementation on oxidative stress in 16 male sprinters. The study found no significant difference between the group given the supplement and the placebo group in terms of muscle damage recovery and exercise performance. However, an increased levels of polyphenols were observed in the supplement group post-exercise in comparison to the placebo group.
Abstract
BACKGROUND Although research suggests that antioxidant supplementation can protect against exercise-induced muscle damage and oxidative stress, also delayed post-exercise muscle recovery and hindered adaptation to training were reported in the supplemented athletes. PURPOSE The purpose of the study was to evaluate the effects of green tea extract (GTE) supplementation on selected blood markers of oxidative stress and muscle damage in sprinters during preparatory phase of their training cycle. METHODS Sixteen sprinters participated in a double-blind, randomized, placebo (PL)-controlled crossover study, including two 4-week treatment periods with PL and GTE (980 mg polyphenols daily). The sprinters performed two repeated cycle sprint tests (RST; 4 × 15 s, with 1-min rest intervals), after PL and GTE supplementation. Blood was sampled before (at rest), 5 min after RST, and after the 24-h recovery. The activities of superoxide dismutase (SOD) and glutathione peroxidase were measured in erythrocytes, and total polyphenols, total antioxidant capacity (TAC), uric acid (UA), albumin (AL), malondialdehyde (MDA), and creatine kinase (CK) were determined in blood plasma. RESULTS Repeated cycle sprint test performed after PL induced an increase in MDA, TAC, and SOD. Moreover, an increase in UA, AL, and CK was observed after RST irrespective of experimental conditions (PL, GTE). Supplementation with GTE caused an increase in total polyphenols and TAC at rest, and a decrease in MDA and SOD after RST. No significant changes in sprint performance were noted after GTE, as compared to PL. CONCLUSIONS Supplementation with GTE prevents oxidative stress induced by RST in sprinters. Furthermore, GTE supplementation does not seem to hinder training adaptation in antioxidant enzyme system. On the other hand, neither prevention of exercise-induced muscle damage, nor an improvement in sprint performance is noted after GTE administration.