Alzheimer’s disease (AD) is a neurodegenerative disorder characterised by progressive memory loss, spatial disorientation, cognitive impairment and behavioural changes. Ageing is the main risk factor for AD, with approximately one-third of Americans over the age of 85 being affected by the condition. The APOE gene provides instructions for making the apolipoprotein E family of proteins that are involved in fat metabolism and cholesterol transport. There are three different variants of this gene, one inherited from each parent. The variant called APOE4 is thought to increase AD risk from 2-3-fold (one inherited copy) to as much as 15-fold (two inherited copies), compared to individuals who do not carry this variant. The omega-3 oil docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) is an essential fatty acid, which comprises approximately 30% of the fats found in the human brain. Low levels of DHA in the brain increase the risk of developing AD, while normal and high levels may prevent the condition and ameliorate symptoms. This review paper brings together several lines of evidence on why individuals with the APOE4 gene variant don’t respond well to DHA supplementation but experience positive effects from dietary intake of DHA. The author suggests that this is due to the different forms of DHA found in dietary and supplemental sources. Some of the DHA present in fish and seafood is in phospholipid form, which is metabolised into lysophosphatidylcholine DHA (DHA-lysoPC) in the body. In contrast, fish oil supplements contain no DHA in phospholipid form, but in other forms that are mostly metabolised to free DHA. This paper puts forward an argument that, due to the breakdown of the integrity of the blood-brain barrier, APOE4 carriers have impaired brain transport of free DHA but not DHA-lysoPC. The author concludes that dietary sources that contain high amounts of DHA in phospholipid form, such as fish and fish roe may help increase plasma levels of DHA-lysoPC, which may be better transported to the brains of APOE4 carriers. She also highlights the pressing need for future clinical trials to evaluate the effects of omega-3 oils in phospholipid form on the cognitive function of APOE4 carriers with AD.